Type of comparator group | No. of comparator groups | Study Sample | Superior/ equivalence – non-superior (n) | Characteristic of intervention with superior/ equivalence outcome (n) | Characteristic of intervention with non-superior outcome (n) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
BA as standalone intervention (n = 3) | |||||
Waitlist/ no treatment/ attention control | – | – | – | – | – |
Clinical monitoring | 1 | 118 | 1–0 | Indicated (1); Treatment (0) | Indicated (NA); Treatment (NA) |
Individual (1); Group (1) | Individual (NA); Group (NA) | ||||
Duration: 35 days | Duration: NA | ||||
Active treatment | 3 | 530 | 0–3 | Indicated (NA); Treatment (NA) | Indicated (0); Treatment (3) |
Individual (NA); Group (NA) | Individual (3); Group (0) | ||||
Parent involved (3) | |||||
Duration: NA | Duration: 84–140 days | ||||
Any comparator | 4 | 648 | 1-3 | Indicated (1); Treatment (0) | Indicated (0); Treatment (3) |
Individual (1); Group (1) | Individual (2); Group (0) | ||||
Parent involved (3) | |||||
Duration: 35 days | Duration: 84–140 days | ||||
BA in multicomponent intervention (n = 22) | |||||
No treatment/ clinical monitoring | – | – | – | – | – |
Waitlist | 9 | 897 | 9-0 | Indicated (7); Treatment (2) | Indicated (NA); Treatment (NA) |
Individual (1); Group (8) | Individual (NA); Group (NA) | ||||
Parent involved (2); Digital (1) | Duration: NA | ||||
Median Duration = 49 days (Range: 28–84) | |||||
Attention control* | 8 | 1205 | 4-4 | Indicated (1); Treatment (3) | Indicated (0); Treatment (4) |
Individual (3); Group (1) | Individual (4); Group (0) | ||||
Digital (3) | Digital (3) | ||||
Median Duration = 56 days (Range: 28–70) | Median Duration = 56 days (Range: 28–84) | ||||
Active treatment* | 18 | 1346 | 8-10 | Indicated (5); Treatment (3) | Indicated (3); Treatment (7) |
Individual (3); Group (6) | Individual (5); Group (5) | ||||
Parent involved (2) | Parent involved (1) | ||||
Median Duration = 56 days (Range: 28–112) | Median Duration = 49 days (Range: 28–84) | ||||
Any comparator | 35 | 2501 | 21–14 | Indicated (13); Treatment (8) | Indicated (3); Treatment (11) |
Individual (7); Group (15) | Individual (9); Group (5) | ||||
Parent involved (4); Digital (4) | Parent involved (1); Digital (3) | ||||
Median Duration = 49 days (Range: 28–84) | Median Duration = 56 days (Range: 28–84) |