Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparison of the basic conditions of the three waste incineration plants siting schemes

From: Towards a better psychological satisfaction: developing a mixed multi-criteria evaluation system to urban ‘Not in my back yard’ facilities siting

Modules

Evaluation criteria

Scheme 1

Scheme 2

Scheme 3

Spatial planning

Public impact

4

3

2

Land size (sqm)

53300

57600

60400

Industrial impact

3

3

2

Landscape impact

1

2

1

Environmental protection

Atmospheric Environmental Impact (ppm)

0.4

0.6

1

Noise (decibels)

8

8

5

Construction-operations

Land cost (10,000 CNY)

1020

920

870

Construction investment (10,000 CNY)

33500

35300

35500

Infrastructure investment (m)

1540

2520

3680

Transportation cost (m)

9800

11500

14400

Operation cost (10,000 CNY per year)

1560

1650

1680

Sociopsychology

Public perception

4

4

2

  1. Qualitative criterion data are determined by the Delphi method and quantitative criterion data are provided by relevant departments
  2. Then, we conducted data preprocessing. Evaluation criteria were divided into two categories, namely qualitative criteria and quantitative criteria, which could be represented by ‘O’ and ‘C’, where:
  3. O = {public impact, industrial impact, landscape impact, public perception}, and is the set of all qualitative criteria
  4. C = {Scale of site, atmospheric impact, noise, land cost, construction investment, infrastructure support, transportation cost, operation cost}, and is the set of all quantitative criteria